Seller Decision
"We buy houses" companies offer speed and certainty, and they charge for it in price: industry estimates commonly put cash offers around 70 to 85 percent of a home's market value. Meanwhile, correctly priced Pittsburgh homes typically sell in 14 to 28 days on the open market, so the time a cash offer saves is often weeks, not months. Sometimes the cash offer is still the right call. This page walks the actual math on a $250,000 example, with every assumption labeled, and is honest about when each path wins.
Get a Free Market Valuation FirstCash-offer companies are not charities, and there is nothing wrong with that. They make money by buying below market value, covering repairs and carrying costs, and reselling. That margin has to come from somewhere, and it comes from your price. Industry estimates commonly cited put cash offers at roughly 70 to 85 percent of a home's market value. That is not our study and every company is different, but the direction is consistent: the convenience is real, and it is paid for out of your equity.
The pitch usually leans on speed and hassle. Both are worth something. But the speed gap is smaller than the advertising suggests: in the Pittsburgh market, a correctly priced home typically sells in 14 to 28 days, with a financed closing following roughly a month after that. A cash sale closes faster, but you are usually buying weeks, not months, and paying a percentage of your house for them.
Here is the comparison sellers rarely see written down. Everything below is illustrative math with labeled assumptions, not a quote, an appraisal, or a promise. Your numbers will differ; the point is to show how to run them.
Assume a home worth $250,000 on the open market, and assume the cash buyer offers 75 percent of market value, the middle of the commonly cited 70 to 85 percent industry-estimate range. That is a $187,500 offer. Cash buyers typically pitch this as "no commission, no repairs, no closing costs," and often that is largely true, though you should read the agreement for fees before assuming it. Call the take-home roughly $187,500 on these assumptions.
Same house, listed at $250,000. Assume it sells at that price, which is what correct pricing is for. Now subtract the real costs: roughly 6 percent commission is $15,000, and other typical Pennsylvania seller costs, your share of the 2 percent transfer tax plus the usual closing items, add several thousand more. Using the typical Pennsylvania all-in seller cost range of 6 to 8 percent, assume roughly $22,500 in total selling costs, the upper middle of that range. That nets roughly $227,500.
On these labeled assumptions: $227,500 by listing versus $187,500 from the cash offer, a difference of about $40,000, in exchange for showings and a few extra weeks. Even if the house needed $15,000 of repairs to sell at full market value, or you priced modestly under market to move fast, the listing path would still come out well ahead in this example. The percentages matter more than the exact figures: a 25 percent discount off the top is very hard for saved commission and closing costs, which run in the single digits, to overcome.
Run your own version of this math with the free Pittsburgh Seller Net Proceeds Calculator, and see what sellers actually take home in What Pittsburgh Home Sellers Actually Net in 2026.
An honest comparison has to include the cases where the cash buyer wins, because they exist. An inherited house in poor condition is the classic one: if the heirs live out of state, the house needs more work than anyone wants to manage, and the estate needs to settle, a discounted certain sale can be worth more than a theoretical full price. An immediate relocation is another, when a job start date makes a guaranteed closing date worth real money. A house with problems severe enough that it might not pass a buyer's financing can be a legitimate cash-buyer situation. And some sellers simply cannot host showings, for health or family reasons, and that constraint is real.
In those situations, the discount is buying something you actually need: certainty, speed, or freedom from the process. The mistake is not taking a cash offer; it is taking one without those circumstances, or without ever learning what the house would bring on the open market. A discount is only a known cost if you know the market number too.
Get both numbers in writing. Take the cash offer, read it for fees and contingencies, and hold it next to a professional comparative market analysis of what the home would sell for on the open market. The valuation is free and carries no obligation, so there is no scenario where you are better off deciding without it. If the cash offer is within a few percent of your realistic net from listing and your situation values speed, take it with a clear conscience. If it is tens of thousands below, you will be glad you checked.
And if speed is the whole concern, know the local baseline first: correctly priced Pittsburgh homes typically sell in 14 to 28 days. The full timeline, and what moves it, is in How Fast Can I Sell My House in Pittsburgh.
The Mario Rudolph Team at Howard Hanna, a family-run team with 175+ closed sales and a 5.0 Zillow rating across 17 verified reviews, will give you a free, no-obligation market valuation of your home across Allegheny, Butler, Washington, and Westmoreland Counties. Hold it next to any cash offer and decide with both numbers in hand. Call (412) 400-2243.
Get your free valuation from the Mario Rudolph Team